ThinkTankWeekly

Extortionate Fees to Convert Property Usage Violate the Fifth Amendment

CATO | 2026-05-27 | americas

Visit original source

ThinkTankWeekly provides a curated entry and summary only. Full text and PDF remain on the publisher's website.

English Summary

The article argues that exorbitant monetary fees imposed by local governments for converting property usage may constitute an unconstitutional taking under the Fifth Amendment. Using the Takings Clause, the authors assert that such fees fail to meet the Nollan/Dolan standard, which requires the government's demand to have both an essential nexus and rough proportionality to the land use. They contend that the massive fees cited in the New York case lack this proportionality, effectively amounting to an unconstitutional seizure of property. The policy implication is that the Supreme Court must rule on whether such excessive monetary demands, absent a direct property interest, can trigger a Fifth Amendment violation, potentially limiting municipal regulatory power.

中文摘要

本文主張,地方政府為改變物業用途而徵收的過高金錢費用,可能構成《憲法》第五修正案下的違憲徵收。作者援引徵收條款(Takings Clause)指出,此類費用未能符合 Nollan/Dolan 標準,該標準要求政府的要求必須具備必要關聯性(essential nexus)和大致比例性(rough proportionality)的雙重條件。他們認為,在紐約案例中引用的鉅額費用缺乏此種比例性,實質上等同於違憲的財產沒收。其政策意涵是,最高法院必須裁定,在缺乏直接財產權益的情況下,是否會觸發第五修正案的違規行為,這或將限制地方政府的監管權力。

Related Entries

  1. 1.
    2026-11-13 | society | 2026-W46

    The article highlights the success of ROOTS Farm and Forest School, arguing that traditional K-12 education often fails to meet diverse student needs, necessitating alternative learning models. ROOTS employs a nature-based, standards-aligned curriculum that integrates core academics with practical, real-world skills, such as gardening, entrepreneurship, and project management. This hands-on approach allows students to learn through application, giving them ownership over their education. The success of this microschool model suggests a policy shift toward legitimizing and expanding educational freedom, allowing parents and communities to access flexible, localized learning environments outside the traditional public school system.

    Read at CATO

  2. 2.
    2026-11-13 | economy | 2026-W46 | Topics: Trade, United States

    The article argues that the executive branch's use of highly discretionary tariff policies, rather than draining corruption, actively enriches and empowers well-connected lobbying firms. This is evidenced by the significant revenue growth of firms like Ballard Partners, which profit by securing favorable exemptions and rates through opaque, non-rules-based processes (e.g., pharmaceutical or metal tariffs). Because the current system allows the executive branch to set rates and exclusions with minimal public process, it naturally favors large corporations that can afford expensive lobbying services. Policy-wise, the analysis suggests that while tariffs are a Congressional power, the problem lies in the sheer degree of executive discretion, necessitating legislative reform to require explicit congressional approval for proposed tariffs.

    Read at CATO

  3. 3.
    2026-11-12 | economy | 2026-W46 | Topics: United States

    CATO argues that government ownership of passenger rail, exemplified by Amtrak, inherently leads to inefficiency, stagnation, and massive subsidies due to political interference. The analysis contrasts this failure with the success of the freight rail sector, which saw sharp increases in productivity and profitability after deregulation and privatization in the 1980s. The core finding is that government intervention, rather than operational issues, is the primary detriment to the industry. Therefore, the policy recommendation is that Congress should repeal costly federal policies and privatize Amtrak, allowing market competition and entrepreneurs to determine viable routes and services.

    Read at CATO

  4. 4.
    2026-11-12 | tech | 2026-W46 | Topics: Taiwan, United States

    The article argues that the CHIPS Act's advanced manufacturing tax credit constitutes a massive, unnecessary subsidy, potentially costing hundreds of billions of dollars. Evidence suggests that much of the subsidized investment was already planned by major chipmakers before the legislation passed, making the credit a windfall profit. Given that the credit disproportionately funds the rapidly expanding AI data center sector—a focus currently facing public backlash—the authors recommend that Congress simply allow the tax credit to expire to curb the subsidy without enacting new restrictions.

    Read at CATO

  5. 5.
    2026-11-11 | americas | 2026-W46 | Topics: Indo-Pacific, United States

    The article argues that modern interpretations of liberalism often misunderstand the core principles of foundational figures like Henry David Thoreau. Using Thoreau's life and writings, the author reframes his 'liberalism' not as a modern statist position, but as a profound commitment to individual conscience and minimal government intervention. Key evidence is drawn from Thoreau's emphasis on self-reliance and his famous declaration that 'government is best which governs least.' The policy implication is a call for a strategic return to prioritizing individual autonomy and civil disobedience against perceived governmental overreach, emphasizing limited governance as a historical American ideal.

    Read at CATO